Look at your numbers and upcost on the product. A need? see drsmoothiebrands.com
That's a tough one, Mike. I know we charge more for a pound of decaf beans, but it is insignificant... $1 difference vs regular. No upcharge for drip or espresso, despite the slight increase in cost. As much as I'd like to say something like "it would be poorly received", I know you are making great effort to source only the best decaf beans you can get your hands on. Maybe it would help sell the idea that you have the best decaf in town?
Maybe if it were in the context of a tiered price structure for all beans - different prices for different coffees, you could do it. So if you charge more for COEs, Organics, other more expensive greens, then decaf follows that pattern. However, if you price like most places, with a single price for a cup o' drip from the airpot, it might be harder to justify. Not sure how you price there.
Let us know what you decide.